Lot 575    

Joseph Henry Sharp, Indian Medicine or Black Robe?
2006, Spring Decorative Arts, June 17
oil on canvas, signed lower right, and titled and signed on verso. Retains original Taos Society price tag and is in its original frame; 25" x 30" (w/o frame), 36" x 41" (w/frame).

Joseph Henry Sharp (1859-1953) is considered the father of the Taos Society of Artists. His extraordinary output of paintings in his long career made him one of the most prolific and prominent painters of the American Indian. Although he is known for his images of the American west, his other accomplishments included years of teaching in Cincinnati and publication of his works in several magazines.

Sharp was born in Bridgeport, Ohio in 1859. When he was a boy, his hearing was severely damaged as a result of a near-drowning incident. At age 12, his father died, and at age 14, Sharp was forced to drop out of school because his hearing loss had deteriorated and was virtually complete. Sharp then moved to Cincinnati to live with his aunt, and it was here that his formal art education began. He managed to enroll in the McMicken School of Design while still working and providing his mother with financial support. Afterwards he continued at the Cincinnati Art Academy and at age 22, he took his first trip abroad to Antwerp. Over the next decade, Sharp would study in Munich, Spain, Italy and Paris with notable artists such as Karl Marr and Cincinnati friend Frank Duveneck. In Cincinnati, Sharp was a student of Henry Farny, another renowned painter of Indians. Sharp insisted on going West and it was suggested by Farny that he study the Pueblo Indians of New Mexico. His first trip was to Santa Fe in 1882. In 1893, Sharp discovered the Taos area, and became fascinated by the mixture of Indian and Spanish cultures. He also began teaching figure painting the year before at the Cincinnati Art Academy, and during the next several years he often split his time between Taos and Cincinnati, where he taught figure painting at the Art Academy. Sharp, however, did not restrict himself to Taos and its inhabitants. He realized that the Plains Indians were moving towards extinction, so he made several trips north, especially to document Indian survivors of the Battle of Little Big Horn.

Having achieved significant success with his artistic pursuits, Sharp resigned his teaching position in Cincinnati in 1902 and split his time between the Crow Agency in Montana and Taos. He was rapidly becoming the most highly regarded portrait artist of American Indians. In Montana alone, Sharp executed over 200 portraits of Plains Indians. After he had exhausted his possibilities at the Crow Agency, he moved permanently to Taos in 1912. From there he continued to work and travel until his death in 1953 at age 93.

While Sharp is revered in the artistic community for the founding of the Taos Society, one can persuasively argue that his contribution to study of the history and culture of the American Indian is far more important. He left behind thousands of paintings, and his documentation of Indian life is unrivaled. It was his constant goal to capture the essence of Indian life during a period when their cultures were slowly deteriorating.

Indian Medicine or Black Robe? is one of Sharp’s more profound, complicated, and provocative works. The subject is an Indian, in this case Elk Foot, seated in a bare interior contemplating his spiritual beliefs. He leans against the wall, staring down at a bundle of eagle feathers—his Indian medicine, while he grapples with the prospect of Christianity, illustrated by the crucifix on the wall. On the back of this painting is an original label, in Sharp’s hand: INDIAN MEDICINE OR BLACK ROBE. The Indian designates the Christian religion by the word "blackrobe" - In his hands is his "spiritual medicine", various charms to keep evil spirits away and propitiate the gods - It is a study of the conflicting emotions between his own religion and Christianity. J.H. Sharp.

Such thematic constructions were not uncommon in Sharp’s work, given his art historical background and his studies in Europe. He often recorded Indian rituals in his work, and he was very much aware of the period of change that was approaching tribes in the frontier. Indian Medicine is expressive of the fragility of their traditions and the perplexities of their situation.



Provenance:  
Ex Collection Marge and Charles Schott


Condition:  
Lined and replaced stretcher, frame repainted.
Sold: $450,000.00
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
E.T. Hurley, Hillside Landscape with Trees,
Lot # 76 - E.T. Hurley, Hillside Landscape with Trees,
etching on paper, signed in the plate and dated 2-25-13, and pencil-signed lower right. A winter scene in a hillside forest. In a modern frame; 11.75" x 8" (plate), 18.25" x 14" (w/frame). Edward Timothy Hurley (1869-1950), Cincinnati painter, photographer, and Rookwood Pottery decorator, he stud... > Item Details
Carved Wall Shelf with Spread-Winged Eagle,
Lot # 634 - Carved Wall Shelf with Spread-Winged Eagle,
American, late 19th-early 20th century, chip and relief carved from laminated boards and assembled with screws. Shelf is supported by the eagle's wings; all mounted to a shield shaped back with an attached leaf drop. Retains an old (likely original) dark finish; 17" high x 18" wide x 9" deep. > Item Details
Three Pieces of Quackenbush Family Armorial Export Porcelain,
Lot # 705 - Three Pieces of Quackenbush Family Armorial Export Porcelain,
ca 1750-1800, of porcelain. A handleless footed tea bowl and saucer and a larger low bowl, Lowestoft-type, all hand painted and banded in cobalt blue and centered with the Quackenbush family arms with monogram MQ in the center for Margaret Quackenbush; unmarked. Tea bowl is 4.25" diameter x 2.25" hi... > Item Details
Early Andrew Newell, Boston Semi-Circumferentor,
Lot # 470 - Early Andrew Newell, Boston Semi-Circumferentor,
in maple or birch with an incised scale from 0-180 and an inset compass with a steel needle; 5" x 10.25". Andrew Newell (1751-1798) made a variety of surveying and other instruments late 18th-century Boston. Later in life, he worked with his son, Joseph, under Newell and Son. > Item Details
E.T. Hurley Artist's Proof, <i>Produce Vendor, Findlay Market</i>,
Lot # 75 - E.T. Hurley Artist's Proof, Produce Vendor, Findlay Market,
hand-colored aquatint on paper, signed in the plate, penciled lower left AP ED. 8 and pencil-signed lower right. An unusual image of Findlay Market. In a modern frame 9.5" x 12.25" (plate), 17.75" x 20" (w/frame). Edward Timothy Hurley (1869-1950), Cincinnati painter, photographer, and Rookwood P... > Item Details
Buffalo Pottery Deldare
Lot # 119 - Buffalo Pottery Deldare "Heirlooms" 14" Serving Tray,
a large Buffalo Pottery Deldare serving tray entitled "Heirlooms" depicting three gentlewomen in colonial garb examining heirloom jewelry around a Queen Anne game table. Signed by the artist W. Foster and marked below with the manufacturer's backstamp and date 1908; 14" x 10.5". > Item Details
Ten Centennial and Columbian Expo Woven Silk Badges, Plus,
Lot # 807 - Ten Centennial and Columbian Expo Woven Silk Badges, Plus,
lot of 10. Includes four woven silk souvenir ribbon badges from the 1893 Columbian Exposition in Chicago, made by the Phoenix Silk Mfg. Co. of Paterson, NJ; 7.5" to 9" long; three woven silk souvenir ribbons from the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia, one of Washington / The Father of Our C... > Item Details
English Campaign Chest of Drawers,
Lot # 280 - English Campaign Chest of Drawers,
solid mahogany drawer fronts and sides/top with oak and pine secondary. A two-piece case, likely a marriage, upper section having 2-over-1 drawer; lower case with 2 full-width drawers. All locks are by the same English manufacturer and are dated 1926. Refinished; 41.75" high x 35.5" wide x 19.5" ... > Item Details
Pair of Diminutive New England Whale Oil Lamps,
Lot # 718 - Pair of Diminutive New England Whale Oil Lamps,
early to mid-19th century, of colorless flint glass, with pressed fonts in a three-part mold, with faceted stems ending in domed, circular feet. Both retain period #1 collars with two thin annular rings and double fluid-burning wick holders, one retaining the original wick caps; 7.75" high to top of... > Item Details
Early Dutch Silver Repoussé Casket,
Lot # 61 - Early Dutch Silver Repoussé Casket,
fully marked with early marks. With swing handles and claw feet, and with stylized repoussé decoration on the sides and an agricultural scene on the lid; 3" high x 4.5" wide by 3" deep, approx. 6.2 ozt (195 g). > Item Details
Chinese Blue and White Planter,
Lot # 830 - Chinese Blue and White Planter,
probably 19th century, stoneware. A large jar having tapered sides, interior and exterior covered with white slip, exterior decorated with foliate elements and pictorial tablets in cobalt blue; 20" high x 22" diameter. > Item Details
Set of Twelve Gorham Sterling Silver Salt Cellars,
Lot # 20 - Set of Twelve Gorham Sterling Silver Salt Cellars,
all marked, with low, squat bodies, flared, rims, and gold-washed interiors. Each is 1.5" diameter, total weight approx. 4.3 ozt (135 g). > Item Details
Boston and Sandwich Figural Banquet Lamp,
Lot # 214 - Boston and Sandwich Figural Banquet Lamp,
ca 1865-1880, and manufactured by the Boston and Sandwich Glass Co. A large banquet or table lamp with tapered, floral engraved font and figural metal stem depicting a "Peeping Tom" ogling a young maiden at a water fountain, mounted on a square, black slate base. Retains period 5" shade holder and N... > Item Details
<i>The Shrine in the Desert</i> by William Meuttman,
Lot # 595 - The Shrine in the Desert by William Meuttman,
oil on canvas, signed lower left W. Meuttman. A Navaho Indian astride a horse inspecting a white man's cross. 13.5" x 19.5" (w/o frame), 18.5" x 24.5 (w/frame). In a moulded gilded wood frame. Verso of canvas with inscription The Shrine in the Desert/New Mexico. William Meuttman (1869-1948) was born... > Item Details
Inlaid Federal Tall Case Clock,
Lot # 725 - Inlaid Federal Tall Case Clock,
probably New York, ca 1800-1810, in mahogany with crotch mahogany veneer, with poplar secondary wood. Decorated with string inlay and with inlaid triangles on the plinth and inlaid rosettes. The brass movement has a repainted dial that reads Osborne's Manufactury Birmingham. Retains weights and a... > Item Details
Joyce McNair, Pair of Domestic Scenes,
Lot # 739 - Joyce McNair, Pair of Domestic Scenes,
first image watercolor on board, signed bottom right Joyce McNair. Two elderly gentlemen with their canes in a desolate town. Gentleman on right is identified on his cane Joe Casser. Second image watercolor on board, signed bottom left Joyce McNair. Image of husband and wife on doorstep of their mod... > Item Details
English Sterling and Enamel Snuff Bottle/Perfume Duo,
Lot # 716 - English Sterling and Enamel Snuff Bottle/Perfume Duo,
marked for Birmingham, 1889-1890, and incuse maker's marks OS and F.S. Of waisted cylindrical form; one-half a perfume bottle with hinged lid and fitted stopper, the other a snuff bottle with screw lid. Decorated in polychrome enamels in the Aesthetic style; 4" long. > Item Details
Pair of Almon Kirk, American Regionalist Street Scenes,
Lot # 740 - Pair of Almon Kirk, American Regionalist Street Scenes,
ca 1930s, oil on canvas, the first signed Almon Kirk lower right, portraying a likely Midwestern street scene, and the second, signed lower left, showing a rural town view with feed mill and truss bridge; 28.5"x 22" (w/o frames); 34' x 28" (w/frames). In contemporary painted wooden frames. > Item Details
Four Pennsylvania Rainbow Rag Runners,
Lot # 395 - Four Pennsylvania Rainbow Rag Runners,
19th century, attributed to the Lancaster County Amish. Three are identical and from the same loom, one is slightly different; 36" x 180" and 41" x 148", respectively. > Item Details
Five Silver Snuff Boxes,
Lot # 192 - Five Silver Snuff Boxes,
all 19th century, English or German, of sterling or silverplate, with hinged lids. Includes a six-sided silver on copper example, 4" long; an elliptical example, hallmarked, of Chester plate, 3.5" x 2.75"; and three oblong examples, one engraved C. Cadle on the lid, 2.75" x 2"; one hallmarked exampl... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: