Lot 808    

Edward S. Godfrey's 7th Cavalry Presentation Sword,
2005, Historic Americana / Nov 16, 17 & 18
Model 1872 Officer's Grade II Presentation sword made by Pettibone and Brothers of Cincinnati. Complete with original chamois leather protective case. Nickel-plated blade with martial acid-etched engravings, and presentation inscription etched in a blued panel with gilt lettering Presented to Major E.S. Godfrey USA, By members of H Troop 7th U.S. Cavalry Dec. 18, '96. On the opposite side of the blade is another blued panel featuring an acid-etched gilded spread-winged eagle. The grip is a white shagreen wrapped with a gold bullion wire, and pommel and knuckle bow of gilded brass. Scabbard of nickel, with carrying rings and the fittings of gilded brass featuring martial motifs and an engraved spread-winged eagle.

The military career of Edward Settle Godfrey (1843-1932) spanned nearly his entire adult life, and involved his participation in each of the major wars of the last half of the 19th century. He served as a private in Co. D of the 21st Ohio Volunteer infantry during the early part of the Civil War. Entering West Point during the war, he graduated in 1867 and was commissioned Second Lieutenant in the 7th Cavalry. He served throughout the Indian Wars, commanding Co. K of the 7th at the battle of the Little Bighorn. He survived the "hilltop" fight with Reno, and the following summer was involved in the campaign against Chief Joseph and the Nez Perce and later received the Medal of Honor for his actions at the battle of Bear Paw Mountain. With the outbreak of the Spanish American War he served in Cuba and in the Phillipines during the insurrection there. He was retired by operation of law in 1907.

Godfrey will perhaps be most remembered for his actions at Little Bighorn. Attached with Benteen's scouting party consisting of companies D, H and K, Godfrey arrived on the hilltop above the valley of the Little Bighorn to find a fluid situation, with Reno's men having arrived from the valley floor confused and panic-stricken. The main body of Custer's command was now under attack several miles away. Later in the afternoon, Reno attempted to join forces with Custer. Unknown to Reno, Custer and his portion of the command were now killed to the last man. Now the Indians turned their attention to Reno. Godfrey and company K were in the lead, with the majority of the command in the rear. As the attack came, Godfrey executed a textbook falling-back movement that not only saved the men in his company, but likely kept Benteen and Reno's command from being overrun. For the next day and a half, Godfrey dug in, along with the remaining members of the 7th, and ultimately survived.

After the Little Bighorn, Godfrey was severely wounded at the battle of Bear Paw Mountain. Despite his wound he continued to command, and was later awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions.

Godfrey served with the 7th for nearly 30 years before being promoted to Major and being transferred to the 1st U.S. Cavalry on December 8, 1896. This sword, given to him a week later, almost certainly commemorates this momentous event in his career. Oddly, he was transferred back to the 7th a year later, serving three years here and then successively until his retirement with the 12th and 9th cavalry.

In a letter sent from Fort Apache, Arizona Territory, on December 15, 1896, addressed only to "Colonel", Godfrey writes of the occasion when he received this sword:

...I had quite a surprise party myself Friday afternoon. The door bell rang and I went out, saw Sergt Lehman and some men and I thought to myself well I wonder what's the trouble now, as I supposed that some order had been issued for a detail to go out! However they all looked happy and smiling and to my astonishment Segt. Lehman began a formal sort of speech and winded up by handing me a beautiful, gold mounted saber with resolutions...Of course, I could not refuse, so I made a short speech of acceptance and the next morning at inspection gave them a more extended talk. I have always been opposed to presents from those under or over in (me) in the service and had I known of their intentions would have stopped them.
Descended directly in the Godfrey family, and consigned by his great-grand-daughter. With a copy of the letter, now in private hands.

All of the brass fittings show most of the gilt. Missing just a faint hint on some of the sharp edges. The blade is mint; just new! The scabbard has ca 98% of the nickel finish. The knuckle-guard shows only faint wear around the sharp edges. This sword was only used in formal dress events. Mint overall look.
Sold: $72,900.00
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Gathering of Civil War CDVs,
Lot # 1257 - Gathering of Civil War CDVs,
including one sharp view of an unmarked, unidentified major or lt. colonel, a Navy Third Assitant Engineer (1864 regulations) with sword and Columbus, Ohio back mark, an army captain by "Brand's, Chicago," two unknown privates, one infantry, one cavalry, a post-war cdv-sized mounted tintype of a eas... > Item Details
Assorted Civil War Drawings by Julian Scott
Lot # 1476 - Assorted Civil War Drawings by Julian Scott
lot of 27, includes a pencil sketch, self portrait of Scott at easel with palette in hand talking to a woman and child, signed and dated lower right 1871, reverse with interior scene with man reading book with wife and daughter at sides, 9" x 12"; PLUS pencil sketch of men bowling on the green with ... > Item Details
38-Star Clamp-Dyed American National Flag,
Lot # 358 - 38-Star Clamp-Dyed American National Flag,
38 stars configured in straight rows with staggered star axis orientation clamp-dyed onto wool bunting. Canvas sleeve with 3 brass grommets with name and address (in Cincinnati) of former owner inscribed on reverse. Colorado as admitted into the Union as the 38th state on August 1st, 1876. 60" x 96"... > Item Details
Scarce Frank James ANS on Receipt,
Lot # 989 - Scarce Frank James ANS on Receipt,
9 x 3.5", In Account with S.F. BAKER & CO., January 4, 1910, Kirksville, Missouri, for a $1.00 purchase of talcum powder. On the verso James has written in pencil: "Kearney, MO June 23rd, 1910. Owe to S. Zeigler for 2 bags oats owe $ before next month. Frank James." After Jesse was killed in the sp... > Item Details
Ten Spanish American War Plates,
Lot # 1779 - Ten Spanish American War Plates,
includes 7 with battleships and three with portraits, various makers from 7" to 8.5" diameter. > Item Details
Springfield Type Musket Cut to Carbine with Tack Decoration,
Lot # 449 - Springfield Type Musket Cut to Carbine with Tack Decoration,
with ca 65 caliber 21.5" round barrel with standard Civil War-style lock, back plate, butt plate and single barrel strap, cut walnut stock with brass tack decoration around butt plate, heavily oxidized surface to metal, total length 34.75". Typical type of weapon sold to Plains Indians after the Civ... > Item Details
Plains Paint-Decorated Powder Horn,
Lot # 70 - Plains Paint-Decorated Powder Horn,
with one solid red band at plug end black band, flanked by red stripes above this band and double red band with red chevrons between, area between bands have diamonds composed of four red painted dots. Spout has original cap, made form horn tip, flush hardwood plug end with wrought iron eye screw t... > Item Details
Group of Wild West & Carnival Shows Photographs,
Lot # 1075 - Group of Wild West & Carnival Shows Photographs,
lot of 4, includes a image by J.D. Raney, St. Louis, Mo. of a wild west type traveling show with all the players standing astride a dirt road with tents in background, men and women in cowboy and Turkish dress, pencil inscription on rear Richard F. Watson, 7.5" x 9.25" on original card stock, 10" x ... > Item Details
War of 1812 Engraved  Powder Horn,
Lot # 57 - War of 1812 Engraved Powder Horn,
engraved with initials MF and Jun 1812, folksy landscape with 2-story home with 2 chimneys, trees, rooster and fenced yard, plus a 3-masted schooner with Masonic symbols and floral and geometric designs, throat with engrailed edge with hexagonal spout, spruce/pine plug end with chip carved geometric... > Item Details
Cabinet Card of Annie Oakley,
Lot # 1068 - Cabinet Card of Annie Oakley,
with imprint of Stacy. The classic pose shown with her chest full of shooting medals. > Item Details
Eclectic Grouping of Early Campaign Ephemera,
Lot # 1678 - Eclectic Grouping of Early Campaign Ephemera,
Group lot of twenty (20) miscellaneous pieces of political ephemera, buttons, badges, ribbons, and like material. Includes four trade cards and a cdv of James Garfield, a glass "Harrison hat," a neat little Cleveland ribbon, and several fun, little badges. > Item Details
* Winchester Model 12 Shotgun,
Lot # 658 - * Winchester Model 12 Shotgun,
16 gauge, serial number 920499. Blued barrel and receiver with walnut stock and forearm. > Item Details
Seven Spanish American War Plates & Dishes,
Lot # 1778 - Seven Spanish American War Plates & Dishes,
includes three ca 9" plates, one calendar, one Dewey portrait and one U.S.S. Maine; PLUS 9" square plate with Dewey portrait; PLUS curved platter with Dewey & Hobson portraits and flag, 12" long; PLUS 13" platter with U.S.S. Maine; AND 14" platter with U.S.S. Maine. > Item Details
Civil War CDVs of Beauregard & Polk,
Lot # 1181 - Civil War CDVs of Beauregard & Polk,
Bishop Polk in vestments and Beauregard as an old army engineer colonel, both early commercial views by Brady. The Episcopal Bishop of Louisiana and Lieutenant General was one of the few high ranking Confederate officers without a resume of pre-war military experience and owed his rank to his perso... > Item Details
Autographed George A. Custer CDV,
Lot # 720 - Autographed George A. Custer CDV,
with an additional carte of his wife, Libbie Bacon Custer. Custer's portrait as a Brigadier General, with Brady's New York and Washington Galleries backmark, taken on October 8, 1863 (K-20), and boldly signed Truly Yours G.A. Custer. Libby's carte with the imprint of W. H. Bowlsby photographer, Mo... > Item Details
Scarce Wyatt Earp/Doc Holliday Books and Pamphlets
Lot # 1056 - Scarce Wyatt Earp/Doc Holliday Books and Pamphlets
lot of 3, includes Wyatt Earp Frontier Marshal by Stuart N. Lake, 1931, Houghton Mifflin Co., Boston & N.Y., 8vo in embossed orange buckram, 392pp with frontis; PLUS Suppressed Murder of Wyatt Earp by Glenn G. Boyer, 1967, The Naylot Co. San Antonio, Tx., 8vo in black buckram with illustrated dj, 13... > Item Details
Pattern Glass Dewey Pitcher & Eight Tumblers,
Lot # 548 - Pattern Glass Dewey Pitcher & Eight Tumblers,
9 pieces. All clear pattern glass with footed pitcher having oval bust portrait of Admiral Dewey with laurel wreath surround, battleship, stacked artillery flags and other martial items, 9" high, plus eight matching tumblers, 4" high. > Item Details
Autographed(?) Photograph of Sitting Bull,
Lot # 827 - Autographed(?) Photograph of Sitting Bull,
3.3" x 5.4" mounted & trimmed to this size, with ms. Sitting Bull and partially obliterated copyright notice. Perhaps by D.F. Barry, ca 1885. Sitting Bull (1834-1890; Hunkpapa Sioux) is known to have sold autographs and photos. He wears a monarch butterfly (said to be one of his medicines) on hi... > Item Details
Group of Three Civil War Diaries,
Lot # 1445 - Group of Three Civil War Diaries,
Michael J. Sater. Diaries, 1862-1865 (lacking 1864). 14th Iowa Infantry. Co. K, three diaries, document. Early in the Civil War, Michael J. Sater was in the thick of the fighting in the western theatre where he and his comrades in the 14th Iowa suffered heavily. His diaries include mentions of the... > Item Details
Set of Five Polychrome Decorated Spanish American War Plates,
ITEMS 1-20 of 20