Lot 808    

Edward S. Godfrey's 7th Cavalry Presentation Sword,
2005, Historic Americana / Nov 16, 17 & 18
Model 1872 Officer's Grade II Presentation sword made by Pettibone and Brothers of Cincinnati. Complete with original chamois leather protective case. Nickel-plated blade with martial acid-etched engravings, and presentation inscription etched in a blued panel with gilt lettering Presented to Major E.S. Godfrey USA, By members of H Troop 7th U.S. Cavalry Dec. 18, '96. On the opposite side of the blade is another blued panel featuring an acid-etched gilded spread-winged eagle. The grip is a white shagreen wrapped with a gold bullion wire, and pommel and knuckle bow of gilded brass. Scabbard of nickel, with carrying rings and the fittings of gilded brass featuring martial motifs and an engraved spread-winged eagle.

The military career of Edward Settle Godfrey (1843-1932) spanned nearly his entire adult life, and involved his participation in each of the major wars of the last half of the 19th century. He served as a private in Co. D of the 21st Ohio Volunteer infantry during the early part of the Civil War. Entering West Point during the war, he graduated in 1867 and was commissioned Second Lieutenant in the 7th Cavalry. He served throughout the Indian Wars, commanding Co. K of the 7th at the battle of the Little Bighorn. He survived the "hilltop" fight with Reno, and the following summer was involved in the campaign against Chief Joseph and the Nez Perce and later received the Medal of Honor for his actions at the battle of Bear Paw Mountain. With the outbreak of the Spanish American War he served in Cuba and in the Phillipines during the insurrection there. He was retired by operation of law in 1907.

Godfrey will perhaps be most remembered for his actions at Little Bighorn. Attached with Benteen's scouting party consisting of companies D, H and K, Godfrey arrived on the hilltop above the valley of the Little Bighorn to find a fluid situation, with Reno's men having arrived from the valley floor confused and panic-stricken. The main body of Custer's command was now under attack several miles away. Later in the afternoon, Reno attempted to join forces with Custer. Unknown to Reno, Custer and his portion of the command were now killed to the last man. Now the Indians turned their attention to Reno. Godfrey and company K were in the lead, with the majority of the command in the rear. As the attack came, Godfrey executed a textbook falling-back movement that not only saved the men in his company, but likely kept Benteen and Reno's command from being overrun. For the next day and a half, Godfrey dug in, along with the remaining members of the 7th, and ultimately survived.

After the Little Bighorn, Godfrey was severely wounded at the battle of Bear Paw Mountain. Despite his wound he continued to command, and was later awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions.

Godfrey served with the 7th for nearly 30 years before being promoted to Major and being transferred to the 1st U.S. Cavalry on December 8, 1896. This sword, given to him a week later, almost certainly commemorates this momentous event in his career. Oddly, he was transferred back to the 7th a year later, serving three years here and then successively until his retirement with the 12th and 9th cavalry.

In a letter sent from Fort Apache, Arizona Territory, on December 15, 1896, addressed only to "Colonel", Godfrey writes of the occasion when he received this sword:

...I had quite a surprise party myself Friday afternoon. The door bell rang and I went out, saw Sergt Lehman and some men and I thought to myself well I wonder what's the trouble now, as I supposed that some order had been issued for a detail to go out! However they all looked happy and smiling and to my astonishment Segt. Lehman began a formal sort of speech and winded up by handing me a beautiful, gold mounted saber with resolutions...Of course, I could not refuse, so I made a short speech of acceptance and the next morning at inspection gave them a more extended talk. I have always been opposed to presents from those under or over in (me) in the service and had I known of their intentions would have stopped them.
Descended directly in the Godfrey family, and consigned by his great-grand-daughter. With a copy of the letter, now in private hands.

All of the brass fittings show most of the gilt. Missing just a faint hint on some of the sharp edges. The blade is mint; just new! The scabbard has ca 98% of the nickel finish. The knuckle-guard shows only faint wear around the sharp edges. This sword was only used in formal dress events. Mint overall look.
Sold: $72,900.00
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Civil War Book,
Lot # 1470 - Civil War Book, "Life in the Confederate Army"- Annotated,
small 8vo, Arthur P. and Marion Johnstone Ford, 1905. Life in the Confederate Army and Some Experiences and Sketches. New York. Ford, a South Carolinian, a member of Manigault's Light Artillery battalion, provides his recollections of the war in this scarce volume, which according to manuscript an... > Item Details
Ninth Plate Civil War Tintype of a Chasseur,
Lot # 1415 - Ninth Plate Civil War Tintype of a Chasseur,
unidentified private, wearing the dark blue single-breasted uniform coat with yellow over green shoulder epaulettes popularized by the Crimean French light infantry, or chasseurs a’ pied. Note the tall garrison cap with distinctive pointed front, a hold-over from Napoleonic days and still worn by t... > Item Details
French Conversion Percussion Musket with Tack Decoration,
Lot # 40 - French Conversion Percussion Musket with Tack Decoration,
with ca 70 caliber 33.5" round to octagonal unmarked barrel with standing front sight, unmarked conversion percussion lock with engraved brass back plate and trigger guard, brass butt plate & 1 ramrod ferrule, cut down and thinned carved maple stock, with checking on wrist, all with nice mellow pati... > Item Details
Signal Cannon Made from Relic Oak of U.S.S. Constitution & Constellation,
Lot # 157 - Signal Cannon Made from Relic Oak of U.S.S. Constitution & Constellation,
ornate cast bronze working muzzle-loading cannon in 18th century style with floral, shield and unclear script, open touch hole and 1" diameter muzzle, mounted on oak deck carriage with oak wheels and iron hardware with brass plate stamped Oak Timbers From U.S. Frigates Constitution Constellation, ca... > Item Details
Rare Catalog of F.A. Rinehart Photographs
Lot # 897 - Rare Catalog of F.A. Rinehart Photographs
small 24mo in printed card stock covers entitled Rinehart's Prints of American Indians, n.p., 1900, Omaha, Neb., with 79pp, nearly half with 3 photomechanical images of Indians. > Item Details
CDV of Two Armed Union Soldiers in Winter Overcoats,
Lot # 1272 - CDV of Two Armed Union Soldiers in Winter Overcoats,
no back mark. A fine view of two bearded infantry officers with M1850 Foot swords wearing private purchase light colored greatcoat with fold-over collar. The shape of an embroidered infantry bugle can just be made out on the kepi of the officer standing at right. The thin trouser stripe confirms ... > Item Details
CDV of Admiral Franklin Buchanan, CSN,
Lot # 1137 - CDV of Admiral Franklin Buchanan, CSN,
published by Anthony after Brady showing Buchanan as a Captain in the US Navy. Buchanan was the proverbial "old salt" having joined the Navy in 1815 as a Midshipman. He resigned his commission in April 1861 and joined the fledgling Confederate Navy as Captain in September 1861. He commanded the CSS... > Item Details
Confederate Cartridges for Colt's Navy Pistol,
Lot # 203 - Confederate Cartridges for Colt's Navy Pistol,
box marked 6 Cartridges Colts Navy Pistol C.S. Laboratory Richmond.VA. [See Malloy, 2003, p. 88: fig. 267] This is one of the best known Confederate cartridges packets for the Army Pistol. > Item Details
Autographed Engraving of Wrong Way Corrigan,
Lot # 1767 - Autographed Engraving of Wrong Way Corrigan,
shoulder length engraving of a smiling Corrigan, signed in print Vernon Hampton and autographed in ink lower right Douglas Corrigan/9-5-38, 9" x 14.5", matted and framed, 13.2" x 19.2". Attached ALS from Corrigan on rear, reads Dear Mr. Knowles/Say thanks for sending those photos, even late that's m... > Item Details
Webley & Scott Flare Pistol,
Lot # 564 - Webley & Scott Flare Pistol,
serial number 124405. Marked on left side of frame Webley & Scott London/Birmingham. All brass and with walnut grips. > Item Details
Rinehart Photo of Custer Battlefield
Lot # 764 - Rinehart Photo of Custer Battlefield
platinum print taken at base of knoll showing stone monument at top with cast iron fence surround and white markers of individual soldiers graves, marked in negative Copyright 1900 F.A. Rinehart, Omaha/The Custer Battle Field Near Crow Agency, Mont.. > Item Details
CDV of Bvt. Captain David Hazzard, 11th US Infantry,
Lot # 1159 - CDV of Bvt. Captain David Hazzard, 11th US Infantry,
by "Whitehurst, Washington" with "D. Hazzard/11th US Infty/April/63" inked on verso. Hazzard joined the regulars as a private in Company F. 11th US Infantry in December 1861 and was promoted through the ranks. He was a 2nd lieutenant at Gettysburg serving in Ayres Division and was brevetted Captain... > Item Details
ID'd <i>Wilder Brigade</i> Spencer Model 1860 Rifle and Bayonet, Plus,
Lot # 292 - ID'd Wilder Brigade Spencer Model 1860 Rifle and Bayonet, Plus,
56-56 caliber serial number 6341, belonging to Private David B. William Co. H 123rd Illinois. Three-band rifle, top of receiver marked Spencer Repeating Rifle Co, Boston, Mass, Patented March 6, 1860. According to the Springfield Research Service this Spencer rifle is in the serial range of the rifl... > Item Details
Enfield P1858 <i>Bar on Band</i> 2-Band Rifle,
Lot # 173 - Enfield P1858 Bar on Band 2-Band Rifle,
577 caliber, barrel length 33". Lockplate marked 1861/Tower over Crown and VR. Butt behind swivel: Beckwith, left stock above trigger, Proctor. Breech with miscellaneous proofmarks. Butt on right side: TOWER-LONDON/1861/WO and 1. Bayonet lug: 1/11/15. This distinctive bar-on-band model is easily ... > Item Details
Morrow Stereoview of Luther
Lot # 937 - Morrow Stereoview of Luther "Yellowstone" Kelly ,
with imprint of Morrow's studio in Yankton, Dakota and title, No. 57 Hand to Hand, showing the frontier scout Luther "Yellowstone" Kelly engaged in mock combat. This is one of a series Morrow shot of Kelly and this Indian depicting Kelly's hand-to-hand combat with an Indian. WITH a cdv w/imprint ... > Item Details
<i>Jonathon Ogden's</i> 1755 Powder Horn,
Lot # 43 - Jonathon Ogden's 1755 Powder Horn,
with two lines of text reading Jonathon Ogden 1755/his horn in Oswego. End engraved with vining plant with hanging berries, the body with a hunter hiding behind a tree and shooting at herd of three deer, a large pine tree with cones and line of many types of birds and one small pinwheel in circle. R... > Item Details
Meerschaum Figural Pipe of Frontiersman,
Lot # 1052 - Meerschaum Figural Pipe of Frontiersman,
with bust of bearded gentleman in broad brimmed hat with long flowing hair and amber stem, 7" long, with wonderful mellow patina, in felt lined fitted hinged leather case marked in gilt G.F.B.. > Item Details
Sixth Plate Cased Tintype of Id'd Policeman,
Lot # 1532 - Sixth Plate Cased Tintype of Id'd Policeman,
seated uniformed officer with great coat, housed in embossed floral paper covered wooden case, with periodical clipping behind image showing the same gentleman only later in life in police uniform with caption Police Chief McElroy. > Item Details
CDV of Brevet Major General Philip St. George Cooke,
Lot # 1187 - CDV of Brevet Major General Philip St. George Cooke,
by Anthony with "Whitehurst" Gallery logo prominently displayed in lower right corner of prop column. Virginia born Cooke was a long serving regular and Colonel of the 2nd Dragoons at the outbreak of war and was soon promoted to Brigadier General, Regular Army in November 1861. He never delivered on... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20